A comprehensive discussion on colour conversion element design of phosphor converted LEDs
© Schweitzer et al.; licensee Springer. 2014
Received: 8 April 2014
Accepted: 7 October 2014
Published: 8 November 2014
For a systematic approach to improve the white light quality of phosphor converted light-emitting diodes (LEDs) for general lighting applications it is imperative to get the individual sources of error for correlated colour temperature (CCT) reproducibility and maintenance under control. In this regard, it is of essential importance to understand how geometrical, optical and thermal properties of the colour conversion elements (CCEs), which typically consist of phosphor particles embedded in a transparent matrix material, affect the constancy of a desired CCT value. In this contribution we use an LED assembly consisting of an LED die mounted on a printed circuit board by chip-on-board technology and a CCE with a globe-top configuration on the top of it as a model system and discuss the impact of the CCE size, the substrate reflectivity as well as the thermal load of the CCEs on CCT maintenance and the respective radiant fluxes. It turns out that optimized solutions for CCT maintenance and high radiant fluxes in regard of one of the relevant influence factors do not need to be optimized solutions in regard of another one.
Although the phenomenon of electroluminescence is known for more than 100 years ,, it took till the early 1990s that efficient blue LEDs, which are the core elements for solid state lighting (SSL), have been available ,. From that time on, a great amount of worldwide industrial and academic research activities resulted in a rapid enhancement of both device performance and life time. Nonetheless, as noted, e.g., in , estimates are that SSL has only reached the halfway point in terms of lighting efficiency, which leaves a lot of challenges ahead—not just in terms of energy efficiency, but also for colour quality and control, as well as other potential advantages which are largely untapped .
For example, it has been concluded that for white LEDs to be commonly accepted for general lighting applications, the colour variation among individual LEDs should become of the order of a 2–step MacAdam ellipse . For several reasons it is hard to meet this demand with today’s most common approach for white LEDs, which relies on the excitation of a phosphor by blue or UV emitting LEDs. The phosphor is part of the colour conversion element (CCE), which typically consists of phosphor particles embedded in a silicone matrix. While this concept seems to be rather trivial, recent studies have highlighted that the lumen output and the white light quality of phosphor converted LEDs critically depend on an appropriate design of the CCEs and are strongly affected by their shape, composition and arrangement within the LED package -.
As shown recently, besides its direct impact on the optical properties, the CCE design has also a strong impact on the thermal load of the CCEs during device operation. Even in the case that most of the heat is generated in the LED die, in today’s LED packages the highest temperatures are often located in the CCE as a consequence of the low thermal conductivity of the silicone matrix . Besides the related risk for long-term materials degradation, this in particularly also has a strong impact on correlated colour temperature (CCT) maintenance. Since phosphors are generally prone to decreasing luminescence intensity with increasing temperature, which means that the overall contribution of the yellow emission decreases, one has to ensure that the temperature increase and variation within the LED package and in particular in the CCE upon device operation is as low as possible. Using one specific Ce doped yttrium aluminum garnet (Ce:YAG) as a reference phosphor, in a recent study it has been concluded that a temperature variation of about 40 K might be just tolerable to limit variations of the CCT values within a MacAdam ellipse of step 2 .
Together with the manufacturing and fabrication processes of the LED packages and their components, which involve a lot of potential failure sources, these are challenging demands which all may influence a desired CCT value and a deviation therefrom. In principle, the shape and the composition of the CCEs can be designed to alleviate the impact of most of the parameters affecting the constancy of a CCT value in each case. However, for a concerted consideration it is often necessary to make compromises in regard of optimized CCE designs, since the optimization of the CCE with respect to one of the influencing factors may negatively affect another one. In a recent publication, we have highlighted this based on a consideration of manufacturing imperfections of colour conversion elements in globe-top configurations . In the following, we extend these studies and show that in dependency of the substrate surface reflectivity and the sizes of globe-tops (which have a hemispherical shape) optimized solutions for CCT maintenance in regard of one of the relevant parameters do not need to be optimized solutions in regard of another one.
In the present study, the CCE is assumed to have a globe-top configuration with a hemispherical shape. In order to study the impact of different globe-top sizes on the optical and thermal properties the radii of these hemispheres are varied from 1 mm, to 2 mm and 3 mm as schematically shown in Figure 1. The phosphor concentrations for these different globe-top sizes are adjusted in order to get similar CIE x values of about 0.3300 (5.115 vol.% for 1 mm, 2.244 vol.% for 2 mm and 1.454 vol.% for 3 mm) and 0.3800 (8.373 vol.% for 1 mm, 3.566 vol.% for 2 mm and 2.299 vol.% for 3 mm) in each case, while the substrate surface is assumed to have a diffuse reflectivity of 85%.
Two wavelengths are considered for the optical simulations : one representing the blue LED light (460 nm), and the other one the converted yellow light (565 nm). It is assumed that only the blue light is absorbed by the phosphor particles, therefore the extinction coefficient of the phosphor particles is set to zero for 565 nm and to 1 × 10−3 for λ = 460 nm. Both the blue LED light and the yellow converted light are scattered throughout the CCE. The simulation of this scattering process is based on the scattering model of Mie and considers the particle size distribution of the phosphor as well as the optical properties of both the matrix material and the phosphor. The refractive indexes of the silicone and the phosphor are kept constant at 1.4 and 1.63, respectively, for both wavelengths. Similarly, the mean diameter of the phosphor particles is kept constant at 7.8 μm with a standard deviation of 4.2 μm. The irradiance distributions both for the blue LED light and the yellow conversion-light are monitored by a detector, which has a hemispherical shape and is centrically placed above the LED package, see Figure 1.
The surface of this detector is divided into 101 × 101 pixels (in direction of the x and y principle axes). Hence, the projection of this surface of the hemispherical detector onto a flat plane gives a matrix consisting of 101 × 101 elements, which e.g., allows one to determine the mean of the CIE x values for two perpendicular directions (line-by-line and column-by-column averaging) of the matrix as a function of the pixel number .
Since the present study mainly focuses on the impact of the CCE and the materials it is composed of, it has to be mentioned that potential impacts which are related to the LED die itself are not considered. This means that, although the optical properties of the LED die are considered in the simulations, these values are assumed to be constant throughout this study. In reality, the absorption and the reflectivity of the light by the LED die may also change due to some long-term degradation .
In order to gain detailed information on the absorption profile of the blue LED light within the CCE, the latter is divided into a number of voxels, each of them having a size of 10 μm × 10 μm × 10 μm (10 μm in each direction). From the ray-tracing simulations, the amount of the blue radiant flux absorbed in each individual voxel can be determined. With the respective overall radiant flux for a specific current as determined from the data sheet , the absolute values of the blue radiant fluxes which are absorbed in each individual voxel can therefore be calculated. These absorption profiles are taken as input data for the subsequent thermal simulations ,, for which three-dimensional models of the LED package were set up using the GPL-software packages GetDP/Gmsh ,. In this case, the CCE is modelled as a unit with a specific thermal conductivity (which is determined by the phosphor concentration in the silicone matrix ) and heat capacity. Using the symmetry of the model, the calculation effort and time can be reduced by simulating only one eighth of the whole sample. The local power sources of the absorption profile in the CCE, however, break this symmetry. Therefore, an equivalent symmetrical CCE-power-source distribution was determined and verified by comparison with full 3D-simulations. At the symmetry planes of this reduced model space, adiabatic boundary conditions were applied.
Two sources for heat generation within the CCE are considered in this study, on the one hand heat generation due to the Stokes shift for those blue photons which are converted into yellow ones (460 nm for the absorbed blue photons and 565 nm for the re-emitted yellow photons) and on the other hand heat generation of those blue photons which are absorbed but which recombine non-radiatively (which is considered for by a quantum efficiency of 70%, which means that 0.7 yellow photons are emitted for each absorbed blue photon) . At the assembly’s bottom face (outside the size range presented in the respective figures) Dirichlet boundary conditions with a temperature of 300 K are assumed. All other boundaries of the model are subject to natural convection in air. The exact value of the coefficient of natural convection h depends on many factors (size of the sample, orientation of the sample in space, ambient temperature, etc.). For the simulations presented in this study, a value of h =20 W/(m2K)  and an ambient temperature of 300 K have been selected.
Results and discussion
In the case of a specular substrate surface reflectivity, the same phosphor concentrations as in case of a diffuse one were used.
An increase of the substrate surface reflectivity to values larger than 85% goes along with an increase of the overall CIE x values for all three globe-top radii. This can be attributed to the fact that with increasing reflectivity the backscattered light becomes less and less absorbed. Since the yellow light emitted from the phosphor particles is more prone to be backscattered than the blue LED light, the substrate reflectivity in particularly affects the yellowish fraction of the overall emission spectrum and therefore also the overall CIE x values increase with increasing substrate reflectivity. In principle, as suggested in , a higher reflectivity of the substrate surface could be therefore applied in order to lower the amount of phosphor which is necessary in order to achieve a desired CCT value. The lowest increase of the CIE x value (and therefore the lowest deviation from the initial value) with increasing substrate reflectivity shows the hemispherical globe-top with the smallest of the three radii since in this case also the coverage of the substrate surface with the globe-top material is the lowest.
This behaviour reverses in case that the reflectivity of the substrate surface is reduced to values lower than 85%. In this case, the overall CIE x values decrease for all the different globe-top radii since a comparably larger amount of the (mainly yellow) backscattered light is absorbed by the substrate surface. Therefore, again, the hemispherical globe-top with the smallest radius shows the lowest decrease of the CIE x values and the lowest deviation from the initial value. In practice, it is most likely that the reflectivity of the substrate surface decreases (and not increases) during the lifetime of the LED assembly because of materials degradation. One can therefore conclude that a smaller globe-top size has some advantages in regard of long-term maintenance of a given colour temperature.
In addition, a comparison of specular and diffuse substrate surface reflectivities shows that for the same value of the reflectivity, a specular reflectivity gives reason for somewhat lower CIE x values than a diffuse one. This behaviour is a bit more pronounced for the larger globe-top radii than for the smaller ones. Since for both types of reflectivity the amount of phosphor is the same (with respect to the individual globe-top radii), the use of diffuse substrate surfaces opens another possibility to reduce the required volume concentration and therefore amount of phosphor to achieve a desired CCT value.
In order to highlight this more in detail, the following approximation can be done, in which hemispheres with the different radii and the respective phosphor concentrations are considered, however the volume of the LED die is neglected. Assuming a density of the phosphor of 4.56 g/cm3 as it is typical for Ce-YAG based systems  and of 0.96 g/cm3, which is an order of range value for PDMS , the required amounts of phosphor for the three globe-top radii in case of the diffuse substrate are given by 0.00048 g (1 mm), 0.00171 g (2 mm) and 0.00378 g (3 mm) for a CIE x value of 0.33 as well as 0.00079 g (1 mm), 0.00272 g (2 mm) and 0.00592 g (3 mm) in the case of a CIE x value of 0.38. Considering the above mentioned differences for specular (for a CIE x value of 0.33 and a globe-top with a radius of 1 mm 0.00049 g, for 2 mm 0.00175 g and 3 mm 0.003841 g would be required) and diffuse substrate reflectivities, this means that in case of a CIE x value of 0.33 and a specular substrate surface reflectivity an about 1% higher amount of phosphor for the globe-top with the radius of 1 mm would be required and an about 2.5% higher amount for the globe-top with the radius of 3 mm.
The same behaviour can be also observed in case of the globe-top with a radius of 3 mm, for which the difference graphs for diffuse and specular reflectivities of the substrate surface are shown in the left column of Figure 4.
A detailed comparison of these images with the images shown in the right column of Figure 3 highlights that for a globe-top with 3 mm radius there are in particular more pronounced differences between diffuse and specular reflectivity for larger viewing angles than in the 1 mm case.
The middle column of Figure 4 shows the difference graphs for the mean of the CIE x values for globe-tops having radii of 1 mm and 3 mm for a diffuse reflectivity. While there is no significant difference for a diffuse reflectivity of 85% (in particular since also the phosphor concentrations were adjusted in order to achieve the same CIE x value of about 0.3300 for the different radii), there is a shift to the bluish with increasing globe-top size for decreasing surface reflectivities and a shift to the yellowish with increasing globe-top size for increasing surface reflectivities. However, for the same type of (diffuse) reflectivity, the globe-top radius has no obvious impact on angular dependent colour variations.
A similar behaviour as in case of phosphor concentrations which give reason for CIE x values of about 0.3300 can also be observed for phosphor concentrations giving reason for CIE x values of about 0.3800. This is emphasized in the images of the right column of Figure 4, which show the difference of the mean of the CIE x values as a function of the pixel number for specular and diffuse reflectivities for globe-top radii of 3 mm.
As a conclusion, these studies show that the colour maintenance is the better the smaller the globe-top radius is and that with a substrate surface having a diffuse reflectivity not only higher CIE x values but also lower angular variations of the CIE x values can be realized.
In addition, a comparison of specular and diffuse reflectivity shows, that the observed lower CIE x values for a specular reflectivity as shown in Figure 2 are mainly caused by a reduction of the yellowish fraction of the light.
Contrarily, in case that the reflectivity of the substrate surface is reduced to 70%, the radiant fluxes decrease. Again, the yellow radiant flux is more affected than the blue one, since a larger portion of the backscattered (mainly yellow) light now becomes absorbed by the substrate surface.
Therefore, and as discussed above, from the viewpoint of CCT maintenance, a globe-top with smaller size is preferable, since such a globe-top configuration shows the lowest deviation from the initial CIE x value in case that the reflectivity of the substrate surface diminishes because of long term materials degradation.
However, this is contradictory to the request of higher radiant fluxes, which are favoured by larger globe-top sizes.
These thermal impacts (higher maximum temperatures and larger temperature variations for different driving currents in case of smaller globe-top radii) again also dimish the aforementioned advantages of smaller globe-top radii in regard of CCT maintenance and restricts their applicability in particular to applications for which the current is not varied upon device operation.
As evident from these studies, which were performed for LED packages with CCEs in globe-top configuration, optimized CCE design in regard of CCT maintenance, radiant fluxes and low thermal load may be counteractive. Considering the fact that the reflectivity of the substrate surface is prone to some long term reduction because of materials degradation, a globe-top of smaller size seems to be preferable in regard of CCT maintenance. On the other hand, a smaller globe-top size gives reason for much higher maximum temperatures within the globe-top during device operation and much larger temperature variations for different driving currents, which again may induce pronounced colour variations and may amplify long-term materials degradation. A compromise based on globe-top configurations of medium sizes therefore seems to be the best strategy to meet all the requirements of colour maintenance, radiant fluxes, and low maximum temperatures at once.
Nonetheless, if only one of these parameters, like colour maintenance or high radiant fluxes is of particular importance for a specific application, the size of the globe-top can be adjusted to meet these requirements at best.
These results in particular highlight the complex interplay of the different effects that contribute to the colour conversion process and finally determine the luminous fluxes and the white light quality of phosphor converted LEDs and the need for the optimization of the CCEs in this regard.
The authors gratefully acknowledge financial support from the “Neue Energien 2020” program, project number 827784, of the Austrian Climate and Energy Fund.
- Round HJ: A note on carborundum. Electrical World 1907, 49: 309.Google Scholar
- Zheludev N: The life and times of the LED — a 100-year history. Nature Photon 2007, 1: 189.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Nakamura S, Senoh M, Mukai T: P-GaN/N-InGaN/N-GaN double eterostructure blue-light-emitting diodes. Jpn J Appl Phys 1993, 32: L8.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Nakamura S, Mukai T, Senoh M: Candela-class high-brightness InGaN/AlGaN double-heterostructure blue-light-emitting diodes. Appl Phys Lett 1994, 64: 1687.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Brodrick J: Solid-State Lighting: Technology at a turning point. [http://apps1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/publications/pdfs/ssl/feb2013_nema_brodrick.pdf]
- Narendran N, Deng L, Pysar RM, Gu Y, Yu H: Performance characteristics of high-power light-emitting diodes. Proc SPIE 2004, 5187: 267.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Xiao H, Lu Y-J, Shih T-M, Zhu L-H, Lin S-Q, Pagni PJ, Chen Z: Improvements on Remote Diffuser-Phosphor-Packaged Light-Emitting Diode Systems. IEEE Photonics J 2014, 6: 8200108.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sommer C, Krenn JR, Hartmann P, Pachler P, Schweighart M, Tasch S, Wenzl FP: The effect of the phosphor particle sizes on the angular homogeneity of phosphor-converted high-power white LED light sources. IEEE J Sel Top Quantum Electron 2009, 15: 1181.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Liu Z-Y, Li C, Yu B-H, Wang Y-H, Niu H-B: Effects of YAG: Ce Phosphor Particle Size on Luminous Flux and Angular Color Uniformity of Phosphor-Converted White LEDs. IEEE/OSA J Disp Technol 2012, 8: 329.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Zheng H, Luo XB, Hu R, Cao B, Fu X, Wang Y, Liu S: Conformal phosphor coating using capillary microchannel for controlling color deviation of phosphor-converted white light-emitting diodes. Opt Express 2012, 20: 5092.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- You JP, Tran NT, Shi FG: Light extraction enhanced white light-emitting diodes with multi-layered phosphor configuration. Opt Express 2010, 18: 5055.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hu R, Luo XB, Liu S: Study on the optical properties of conformal coating light-emitting diode by Monte Carlo simulation. IEEE Photonics Technol Lett 2011, 23: 1673.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yang T-H, Chen C-C, Chen C-Y, Chang Y-Y, Sun C-C: Essential Factor for Determining Optical Output of Phosphor-Converted LEDs. IEEE Photonics J 2014, 6: 8200209.Google Scholar
- Sun C-C, Chen C-Y, Chen C-C, Chiu C-Y, Peng Y-N, Wang Y-H, Yang T-H, Chung T-Y, Chung C-Y: High uniformity in angular correlated-color-temperature distribution of white LEDs from 2800K to 6500K. Opt Express 2012, 20: 6622.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sommer C, Hartmann P, Pachler P, Schweighart M, Tasch S, Leising G, Wenzl FP: A detailed study on the requirements for angular homogeneity of phosphor converted high power white LED light sources. Opt Mater 2009, 31: 837.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hu R, Luo XB, Feng H, Liu S: Effect of phosphor settling on the optical performance of phosphor-converted white light-emitting diode. J Lumin 2012, 132: 1252.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Chang-Chien CL, Huang YC, Yip MC, Fang W: 'Flip glass substrate' package technology for LED yield and performance enhancement. J Micromech Microeng 2012, 22: 105039.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sommer C, Reil F, Krenn JR, Hartmann P, Pachler P, Hoschopf H, Wenzl FP: The Impact of Light Scattering on the Radiant Flux of Phosphor-Converted High Power White Light-Emitting Diodes. J Lightwave Technol 2011, 29: 2285.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Liu Z-Y, Li C, Yu B-H, Wang Y-H, Niu H-B: Uniform white emission of WLEDs realized by multilayer phosphor with pyramidal shape and inversed concentration distribution. IEEE Photonics Technol Lett 2012, 24: 1558.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lin M-T, Ying S-P, Lin M-Y, Tai K-Y, Tai S-C, Liu C-H, Chen J-C, Sun C-C: Ring Remote Phosphor Structure for Phosphor-Converted White LEDs. IEEE Photonics Technol Lett 2010, 22: 574.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sommer C, Reil F, Krenn JR, Hartmann P, Pachler P, Tasch S, Wenzl FP: The impact of inhomogeneities in the phosphor distribution on the device performance of phosphor-converted high power white LED light sources. J Lightwave Technol 2010, 28: 3226.Google Scholar
- Hsiao S-L, Hu N-C, Cornelissen H: Phosphor-converted LED modeling using near-field chromatic luminance data. Opt Express 2013, 21: A250.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Li Z-T, Tang Y, Liu Z-Y, Tan Y-E, Zhu B-M: Detailed Study on Pulse-Sprayed Conformal Phosphor Configurations for LEDs. IEEE/OSA J Disp Technol 2013, 9: 433.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Chen C-Y, Yang T-H, Hsu C-H, Sun C-C: High-Efficiency White LED Packaging With Reduced Phosphor Concentration. IEEE Photonics Technol Lett 2013, 25: 694.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Fulmek P, Sommer C, Hartmann P, Pachler P, Hoschopf H, Langer G, Nicolics J, Wenzl FP: On the Thermal Load of the Color-Conversion Elements in Phosphor-Based White Light-Emitting Diodes. Adv Opt Mater 2013, 1: 753.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sommer C, Hartmann P, Pachler P, Hoschopf H, Wenzl FP: White light quality of phosphorconverted light-emitting diodes: A phosphor materials perspective of view. J Alloys Compd 2012, 520: 146.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sommer C, Fulmek P, Nicolics J, Schweitzer S, Nemitz W, Hartmann P, Pachler P, Hoschopf H, Schrank F, Langer G, Wenzl FP: Thermal and optical aspects of glob-top design for phosphor converted white LED light sources. Proc SPIE 2013, 8835: 88350J.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Cree EZ1000™ Gen I Data Sheet. [http://www.cree.com]
- Kim H, Kim KK, Lee SN, Baik KH: Design and fabrication of vertical-injection GaN-based light-emitting diodes. Opt Express 2011, 19: A937.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wenzl FP, Sommer C, Hartmann P, Pachler P, Hoschopf H, Langer G, Fulmek P, Nicolics J: The impact of the non-linearity of the radiant flux on the thermal load of the color conversion elements in phosphor converted LEDs under different current driving schemes. Opt Express 2013, 21: A439.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Open source software packages: Gmsh: a three-dimensional finite element mesh generator with built-in pre- and post-processing facilities, GetDP: a general environment for the treatment of discrete problems. [http://www.geuz.org]
- Geuzaine C, Remacle J-F: A 3-D finite element mesh generator with built-in pre- and post-processing facilities. Int J Numer Methods Eng 2009, 79: 1309.MATHView ArticleMathSciNetGoogle Scholar
- Enigl R: Master Thesis, AEM-ISAS. University of Technology Vienna; 2000Google Scholar
- Physical properties of CE:YAG. [http://www.scientificmaterials.com/products/ce-yag.php]
- Material safety data sheet Polydimethylsiloxane. [http://www.essentialingredients.com/msds/Element%2014%20PDMS%20350.pdf]
- Yan B, Tran NT, You J-P, Shi F-G: Can Junction Temperature Alone Characterize Thermal Performance of White LED Emitters? IEEE Photonics Technol Lett 2011, 23: 555.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hu R, Luo XB, Zheng H: Hotspot location shift in the high power phosphor converted white light-emitting diode package. Jpn J Appl Phys 2012, 51: 09MK05.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited.